Serving DFW, Austin, McKinney and More.

Facebook Instagram Youtube
CALL US NOW

The Pros and Cons of Different Roofing Materials: Comparing Asphalt, Metal, and Tile Roofs for Texas Homeowners

Close-up of roofing materials for residential roof replacement in Dallas-Fort Worth.

Author / Reviewer:

Author: Hollis Moore  |  Reviewer: Jordan Jackson

Choosing the right roofing material for your Texas home starts with understanding a roofing materials comparison Texas homeowners can trust. This critical decision impacts not only your home’s durability but also its energy efficiency, maintenance needs, and long-term costs. Wortham Brothers Roofing has helped North Texas homeowners navigate this exact decision since 1986, across more than 128,000 completed roofs. Every homeowner faces a unique combination of budget, style preference, and exposure to Texas’s extreme weather conditions—ranging from hailstorms to blistering heat. While asphalt shingles, metal roofs, and tile roofs are all popular options, each comes with distinct advantages and trade-offs. This guide will walk you through the pros and cons of these roofing materials so you can make an informed, value-driven decision for your home.

BBB A+ Since 1992
Owens Corning Platinum Preferred
GAF Certified
CertainTeed ShingleMaster
128,000+ Roofs Installed
Roofing materials comparison Texas featuring a custom standing seam metal roof installed by Wortham Brothers Roofing on a home in the Josey Ranch neighborhood of Carrollton, TX.
Beautiful standing seam metal roofing enhances this custom home in Carrollton’s Josey Ranch neighborhood with lasting durability and modern curb appeal.

Asphalt Shingles: The Most Popular and Affordable Roofing Option

Asphalt shingles remain the most widely used roofing material in Texas due to their affordability, ease of installation, and aesthetic versatility. Installed cost typically runs $8,000–$15,000 for an average North Texas home. They are available in two primary types: three-tab shingles and architectural (dimensional) shingles — both common in WBR’s asphalt roofing services, including product lines like Owens Corning Duration and Duration Storm, and GAF Timberline HDZ.

Pros

  • Cost-effective and budget-friendly ($8,000–$15,000 installed)
  • Wide range of styles and colors to match any home
  • Quick and easy to install or repair (typically 1–3 days)
  • Class 4 impact-resistant options available for better storm protection
  • Manufacturer warranties often range from 25 years to lifetime coverage

Cons

  • Shorter lifespan (typically 15–30 years) compared to other materials
  • More prone to storm damage — granule loss and tearing — unless upgraded to Class 4
  • Absorbs heat, which can increase attic temperatures if ventilation is inadequate

Asphalt shingles are ideal for homeowners seeking affordability and fast installation — especially when enhanced with Class 4 shingles for better storm resistance.

WBR FIELD INSIGHT: Asphalt Shingles

Across our North Texas service area, architectural asphalt with a Class 4 rating is consistently the most-requested upgrade we install for homeowners replacing storm-damaged roofs. The modest price difference over standard three-tab shingles is frequently offset by insurance premium discounts — making it one of the better value decisions a homeowner can make at claim time.

Metal Roofing: Durable, Energy-Efficient, and Storm-Ready

Metal roofing is increasingly popular in Texas thanks to its resilience against extreme weather and excellent energy efficiency. Installed cost typically runs $15,000–$30,000+ depending on panel style and home size. Available in standing seam panels or metal shingles, metal roofs provide a clean, modern look and outstanding durability. Many homeowners explore metal options when considering metal roof installations through WBR.

Pros

  • Exceptional longevity (40–70 years lifespan)
  • Superior resistance to high winds, hail, and fire
  • Reflects UV rays, helping reduce attic heat gain and cooling costs
  • Low maintenance needs over time
  • Eco-friendly — often made with recycled materials

Cons

  • Higher upfront installation cost ($15,000–$30,000+)
  • Potential noise during heavy rain (mitigated with proper insulation)
  • Expansion and contraction with temperature swings require expert installation
  • Hail may leave cosmetic dents, though performance remains unaffected

Metal roofing is perfect for Texas homeowners seeking a long-lasting, energy-efficient, storm-resistant solution — particularly those planning to stay in their home long-term.

WBR FIELD INSIGHT: Metal Roofing

One of the most common questions we hear about metal roofing is whether rain noise is actually a problem. With proper attic insulation and solid decking — standard on every WBR metal install — homeowners typically report the noise difference from inside the home is far less noticeable than expected.

Not Sure If Metal Is Worth The Upfront Jump?

A WBR Account Manager can walk your specific roof and budget through the real numbers — no pressure, just honest answers.

→ Schedule A Free Inspection

Tile Roofing: Timeless Aesthetics and Superior Longevity

Tile roofs — including clay and concrete tiles — are highly regarded for their classic appearance and unmatched longevity. They are especially popular on Spanish, Mediterranean, and Southwestern-style homes throughout North Texas. Installed cost typically runs $20,000–$40,000+, reflecting both material and the structural engineering often required to support the additional weight. These roofing systems are part of WBR’s specialized offerings, including clay tile and concrete tile roofing.

Pros

  • Extremely long lifespan (50–100 years with proper care)
  • Upscale, timeless curb appeal
  • Fire-resistant and impervious to insects and rot
  • Excellent insulation that naturally reduces cooling loads
  • Minimal long-term maintenance

Cons

  • Higher installation cost than asphalt and metal ($20,000–$40,000+)
  • Heavyweight requires reinforced roof structures — a structural assessment is typically needed before installation
  • Fragile when walked on, making maintenance delicate
  • Longer installation times (often 5–10 days)

Tile roofing is a premium option for homeowners seeking standout aesthetics and exceptional durability, particularly on homes architecturally suited to the look.

Close-up comparison of damaged natural slate roof tiles inspected by Wortham Brothers Roofing at a home in Arlington's Heritage Gardens neighborhood.
Close-up images showing cracked and displaced natural slate roofing tiles documented during a roof inspection in Heritage Gardens, Arlington, TX.

Local Project Spotlight: Arlington, TX — Heritage Gardens

In Arlington’s Heritage Gardens neighborhood, a homeowner came to Wortham Brothers Roofing with a problem that’s tricky to get right: damaged natural slate tiles on a roof where appearance and authenticity mattered as much as weather protection. Slate is one of the most demanding materials to repair correctly, since replacement tiles must be matched in color, texture, and thickness to blend seamlessly with decades-old original material — a mismatch is immediately visible on a roof this distinctive.

WBR Project Manager Parker Norris led the repair, carefully sourcing and installing replacement natural slate tiles to match the home’s existing roofline. Rather than recommending a full tear-off, the team focused the repair on the specific broken and compromised tiles, preserving as much of the original slate as possible. The result restored both the roof’s weather protection and the architectural character that drew the homeowner to a slate roof in the first place — proof that the right repair, done carefully, can outperform a full replacement on both cost and preserving a home’s character.

This project reflects a broader point about tile and slate roofing: these are not commodity materials, and not every roofing contractor is equipped to repair them correctly. Matching natural slate requires both sourcing access and installation expertise that go beyond standard asphalt or even concrete tile work — exactly the kind of project WBR’s tile and slate specialists are built to handle.

Key Considerations Processing a Roofing Materials Comparison in Texas

When deciding between asphalt, metal, or tile, consider the following:

Factor What To Know
Budget Constraints Asphalt = most affordable ($8,000–$15,000). Metal and tile = higher upfront cost, lower long-term cost.
Weather Resilience Metal and Class 4 asphalt shingles excel in hail-prone areas. Tile also provides exceptional durability.
Energy Efficiency Metal and tile naturally reflect or insulate heat better than standard shingles.
Home Architecture Tile suits Mediterranean/Spanish styles, metal fits modern or farmhouse looks, asphalt matches nearly any architecture.
Longevity Plans Staying long-term? Metal (40–70 yrs) or tile (50–100 yrs) provides superior value over a 15–30 year asphalt roof.
Insurance Savings Class 4 asphalt shingles and metal roofs frequently qualify for carrier premium discounts — confirm specifics with your provider.

Class 4 asphalt shingles and metal roofs frequently qualify for insurance discounts — similar to the savings outlined in WBR’s guide on impact-resistant roofing benefits.

Custom standing seam metal roof accent paired with Owens Corning Duration Storm Class 4 shingles in Estate Gray on a home in Lucas County Estates, Allen, TX.
A custom metal roof feature complements Owens Corning Duration Storm Class 4 shingles in Estate Gray during this premium roof replacement in Allen’s Lucas County Estates neighborhood.

Local Project Spotlight: Allen, TX — Lucas County Estates

In Allen’s Lucas County Estates neighborhood, a homeowner wanted a roof that delivered serious storm protection without compromising on curb appeal — a combination that’s harder to find than it sounds. WBR Project Manager Steven Mitchell designed a custom roofing system built around Owens Corning Duration Storm Class 4 shingles in Estate Gray, giving the home a roof engineered to resist cracking and granule loss from hail impact while keeping the clean, upscale look the homeowner wanted.

To add architectural definition, the project paired the Class 4 asphalt field with a standing seam metal roof accent on select rooflines — a detail that introduces the long-term durability and modern visual contrast of metal without the cost of a full metal roof replacement. It’s an approach WBR frequently recommends for homeowners who want metal’s distinctive look on key sightlines while keeping the bulk of the roof on a more budget-friendly, still storm-rated material.

The result is a roof built around Class 4 impact resistance as its core protection strategy, with metal used deliberately as a design accent rather than a structural compromise — proof that storm-rated and striking aren’t mutually exclusive in North Texas roofing.

A Note On Insurance Claims And Roofing Materials

If your roof replacement is being driven by storm damage, it’s worth understanding how your material choice interacts with your insurance claim. Most policies are written as either Actual Cash Value (ACV), which factors in depreciation, or Replacement Cost Value (RCV), which covers the full cost to replace the roof.

Regardless of policy type or material chosen, Texas Insurance Code §707.002 requires that deductibles be paid by the homeowner — WBR never waives or absorbs deductibles on any project.

Wortham Brothers Roofing team with founders David and Steve Wortham in Dallas TX
The Wortham family and team behind Wortham Brothers Roofing, serving Dallas–Fort Worth homeowners since 1986.

Make an Investment That Pays Off with Wortham Brothers Roofing

Don’t let confusion or guesswork dictate one of the most important decisions for your home. Wortham Brothers Roofing brings decades of hands-on experience helping Texas homeowners select roofing materials that deliver maximum durability, energy efficiency, and long-term value. Whether you’re considering the affordability of asphalt, the storm-proof durability of metal, or the timeless beauty of tile, our Account Managers will walk you through every option — making sure your roof is built to withstand Texas weather and protect your investment for years to come. Every WBR installation is backed by a lifetime material warranty and a transferable 10-year workmanship warranty.

PROTECTING TEXAS ROOFS SINCE 1986

Not Sure What Your Roof Needs? Start Here.

WBR provides free, photo-documented inspections with honest recommendations — repair, replacement, new build, or commercial. No pressure. No obligation. Just answers.

SCHEDULE YOUR FREE INSPECTION

Frequently Asked Questions

Asphalt, Metal & Tile Roofing for Texas Homeowners — Honest Answers From a Family-Owned DFW Roofer Since 1986

What is the most cost-effective roofing material for North Texas homes?
Asphalt shingles remain the most cost-effective option for most North Texas homeowners, typically running $8,000–$15,000 installed for an average home, compared to $15,000–$30,000+ for standing seam metal or $20,000–$40,000+ for clay or concrete tile. Asphalt also offers the widest range of Class 4 impact-resistant options, which can qualify homeowners for insurance premium discounts in hail-prone areas like McKinney, Allen, and Plano.
Does metal roofing really last longer than asphalt shingles in Texas?
Yes — standing seam metal roofing typically lasts 40–70 years versus 20–30 years for architectural asphalt shingles like GAF Timberline HDZ or Owens Corning Duration. Metal also reflects more solar heat, which can lower summer cooling costs in North Texas. The tradeoff is upfront cost: metal runs roughly 2–3x the price of asphalt installation.
Is tile roofing a good fit for North Texas weather?
Clay and concrete tile hold up well to UV exposure and fire but are more vulnerable to cracking from direct hail impacts than Class 4 asphalt or metal — a real consideration given DFW’s frequent severe hailstorms. Tile is also significantly heavier, often requiring additional structural support verification before installation, which adds cost and time to the project.
Which roofing material performs best against North Texas hailstorms?
Class 4 impact-resistant asphalt shingles and standing seam metal roofing both perform well against hail, though metal can show cosmetic denting that doesn’t always affect function. Class 4 shingles are engineered to resist cracking and granule loss from hail impact and are available across most major lines WBR installs, including OC Duration Storm and GAF Timberline AS II.
Can I get an insurance discount for choosing impact-resistant roofing?
Many Texas insurance carriers offer premium discounts for Class 4 impact-resistant roofing materials, though discount amounts vary by carrier and policy. Homeowners should confirm specifics directly with their insurance provider. Note that under Texas Insurance Code §707.002, deductibles must be paid by the homeowner and cannot be waived or absorbed by the roofing contractor, regardless of material chosen.
How long does each roofing material take to install?
A standard asphalt shingle roof on an average North Texas home typically takes 1–3 days to install. Standing seam metal roofing usually takes 3–7 days due to custom panel fabrication and detailed flashing work. Tile roofing often takes the longest, frequently 5–10 days, due to its weight and the precision required for proper installation.
Does WBR install metal and tile roofing, or only asphalt shingles?
Wortham Brothers Roofing installs asphalt, metal, and tile roofing systems for North Texas homeowners. As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, GAF Certified, and CertainTeed ShingleMaster contractor, WBR can walk homeowners through material options and provide a free on-site comparison specific to their home’s structure, budget, and insurance situation.
What roofing warranty does WBR offer regardless of material?
WBR backs installations with a lifetime material warranty plus a transferable 10-year workmanship warranty, regardless of whether the homeowner chooses asphalt, metal, or tile. This workmanship warranty is one of the stronger protections available in the North Texas roofing market and transfers to a new owner if the home is sold.
Which roofing material adds the most resale value in North Texas?
Metal and tile roofing tend to add more perceived resale value due to longevity and curb appeal, but architectural asphalt shingles still offer the best return relative to upfront cost for most DFW homes, since the price difference is rarely fully recovered at resale. The right choice often depends on how long the homeowner plans to stay in the home.
How do I know which roofing material is right for my home?
The right material depends on your budget, roof structure, how long you plan to stay in the home, and your local hail risk. A WBR Account Manager can provide a free inspection and walk through real cost, lifespan, and insurance tradeoffs for your specific property — call 817-ROOFING (766-3464) to schedule.
Schedule a Free Inspection

Free Inspection

SCHEDULE YOUR FREE ROOF INSPECTION

Wortham Brothers Roofing provides thorough inspections with photo documentation and honest recommendations — no pressure, no obligation.

Schedule Free Inspection
  • ✓ BBB A+ Accredited Since 1992
  • ✓ 40+ Years In Business
  • ✓ OC Platinum Preferred Contractor
  • ✓ 128,000+ Roofs Installed
  • ✓ Free, No-Pressure Inspections

More Roofing Insights

Protecting Texas Roofs Since 1986

Not Sure What Your Roof Needs? Start Here.

WBR provides free, photo-documented inspections with honest recommendations — repair, replacement, new build, or commercial. No pressure. No obligation. Just answers.

Schedule Your Free Inspection